Zipcode Saver logo

The best-rated Italian restaurants in Naples.

10 places across Old Naples, Central Naples, North Naples and East Naples, ranked by Google rating weighted by how many people rated them. La Salière Naples leads with 4.9 stars from 1,818 reviews.

At a glance

  1. La Salière Naples · 4.9★ (1,818) · Old Naples · $$$
  2. Caffé Milano Naples · 4.8★ (6,865) · Old Naples · $$
  3. Mediterrano · 4.8★ (1,290) · Old Naples · $$$
  4. Slicers Hoagies · 4.8★ (854) · Central Naples · $
  5. Limoncello Naples · 4.7★ (1,245) · North Naples · $$
  6. Santi´s New York Pizza · 4.8★ (332) · East Naples · $$
  7. Mercato Italiano · 4.8★ (245) · Old Naples · $$
  8. San Giuseppe Pizza · 4.7★ (585) · North Naples · $
  9. Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew · 4.7★ (582) · East Naples · $
  10. Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria · 4.7★ (338) · Central Naples · $$

Get the Naples Business of the Month coupon, free by text.

Plus new local deals, 2–4 texts a month. Free.

By tapping "Get the coupon" I agree to receive recurring autodialed marketing text messages from ZipCode Saver about the Business of the Month and new local offers. 2–4 messages per month, plus the coupons I claim. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP anytime. Privacy Policy · Terms

  1. La Salière Naples, Italian restaurant in Old Naples, Naples FL La Salière Naples · via Google

    1. La Salière Naples

    4.9 (1,818) on Google
    Restaurants · Old Naples · $$$

    Diners like this restaurant's delicious and authentic Italian food, with many highlighting the fresh ingredients and generous portions of dishes like lasagna, chicken parmesan, and truffle pasta. They also frequently mention the warm, inviting atmosphere and the exceptional, attentive service from the staff.

    Summarized with Gemini from Google reviews
    • Brunch
    • Outdoor seating
    • Cocktails
    360 12th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
  2. Caffé Milano Naples, Italian restaurant in Old Naples, Naples FL Caffé Milano Naples · via Google

    2. Caffé Milano Naples

    4.8 (6,865) on Google
    Restaurants · Old Naples · $$

    Casual Italian restaurant serving pizza, pasta, sandwiches & cocktails in a modern space.

    From Google
    • Brunch
    • Outdoor seating
    • Vegetarian options
    • Cocktails
    800 5th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
  3. Mediterrano, Italian restaurant in Old Naples, Naples FL Randys World · via Google

    3. Mediterrano

    4.8 (1,290) on Google
    Restaurants · Old Naples · $$$

    Bright, turquoise-hued eatery offering upscale Mediterranean cuisine & umbrella-shaded patio tables.

    From Google
    • Outdoor seating
    • Vegetarian options
    • Cocktails
    336 13th Ave S, Naples, FL 34102
  1. Slicers Hoagies, Italian restaurant in Central Naples, Naples FL Slicers Hoagies · via Google

    4. Slicers Hoagies

    4.8 (854) on Google
    Restaurants · Central Naples · $

    People say this sandwich shop offers delicious, inventive subs with generous portions of fresh meat and quality ingredients, including unique options like crushed chips. They also highlight the friendly, welcoming, and efficient staff who provide quick service. Guests mention the overall great value and the lively, chill environment.

    Summarized with Gemini from Google reviews
    • Outdoor seating
    • Dogs allowed
    • Good for kids
    13040 Livingston Rd, Naples, FL 34105
  2. Limoncello Naples, Italian restaurant in North Naples, Naples FL Cheri Morelli · via Google

    5. Limoncello Naples

    4.7 (1,245) on Google
    Restaurants · North Naples · $$

    Casually elegant Italian restaurant featuring a full bar with happy hour & live entertainment.

    From Google
    • Outdoor seating
    • Vegetarian options
    • Cocktails
    • Good for kids
    13800 Tamiami Trl N, Naples, FL 34110
  3. Santi´s New York Pizza, Italian restaurant in East Naples, Naples FL Britney Gutiérrez · via Google

    6. Santi´s New York Pizza

    4.8 (332) on Google
    Restaurants · East Naples · $$

    Diners like this pizzeria's delicious New York-style pizza, especially the Grandma pizza, and mention the generous portions and fresh, high-quality ingredients. They also highlight the reasonable prices and the spotless, well-maintained dining areas. Guests mention the staff are friendly, welcoming, and provide excellent service.

    Summarized with Gemini from Google reviews
    • Outdoor seating
    • Dogs allowed
    • Vegetarian options
    • Good for kids
    7087 Radio Rd, Naples, FL 34104
  4. Mercato Italiano, Italian restaurant in Old Naples, Naples FL Gene Simco · via Google

    7. Mercato Italiano

    4.8 (245) on Google
    Restaurants · Old Naples · $$

    People say this Italian market offers authentic Italian cuisine, including delicious pizzas, fresh pasta dishes, and exceptional pastries and coffee. They also highlight the welcoming and cozy atmosphere, along with the friendly and attentive staff.

    Summarized with Gemini from Google reviews
    • Breakfast
    306 Tamiami Trl N, Naples, FL 34102
  5. San Giuseppe Pizza, Italian restaurant in North Naples, Naples FL Jon Muccio · via Google

    8. San Giuseppe Pizza

    4.7 (585) on Google
    Restaurants · North Naples · $

    People say this pizzeria offers delicious New York-style and Grandma pizzas with a perfect crispy crust and fresh ingredients. They also highlight the reasonable prices, especially the lunch specials, and the clean, inviting atmosphere. Guests mention the staff are very friendly, welcoming, and provide great service.

    Summarized with Gemini from Google reviews
    • Vegetarian options
    • Good for kids
    2400 Vanderbilt Beach Rd #104, Naples, FL 34109
  6. Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew, Italian restaurant in East Naples, Naples FL Yuri · via Google

    9. Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew

    4.7 (582) on Google
    Restaurants · East Naples · $

    Trendy spot offering artisanal pies with creative toppings, plus carefully sourced beers & sodas.

    From Google
    • Outdoor seating
    • Vegetarian options
    • Good for kids
    3802 Tamiami Trl E, Naples, FL 34112
  7. Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria, Italian restaurant in Central Naples, Naples FL Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria · via Google

    10. Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria

    4.7 (338) on Google
    Restaurants · Central Naples · $$

    Diners like this Italian restaurant's authentic New York-style pizza, which features a delicious crust and sauce, along with other fresh, homemade Italian dishes like chicken parmesan and lasagna. They also highlight the friendly and attentive staff, who provide excellent service. Guests mention the reasonable prices and the comfortable, family-style atmosphere.

    Summarized with Gemini from Google reviews
    • Outdoor seating
    • Good for kids
    4910 Tamiami Trl N #124, Naples, FL 34103

Get the Naples Business of the Month coupon. Free, by text.

Plus new local deals, 2–4 texts a month. Free.

By tapping "Get the coupon" I agree to receive recurring autodialed marketing text messages from ZipCode Saver about the Business of the Month and new local offers. 2–4 messages per month, plus the coupons I claim. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP anytime. Privacy Policy · Terms

Italian restaurants in Naples: common questions

What are the best Italian restaurants in Naples, FL?

Ranked by Google rating weighted by review count, the top three are La Salière Naples (4.9 stars from 1,818 Google reviews, Old Naples), Caffé Milano Naples (4.8 stars from 6,865 Google reviews, Old Naples) and Mediterrano (4.8 stars from 1,290 Google reviews, Old Naples).

Which of these Italian restaurants have outdoor seating?

Google lists La Salière Naples, Caffé Milano Naples, Mediterrano, Slicers Hoagies, Limoncello Naples, Santi´s New York Pizza, Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew and Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria as places that have outdoor seating.

Which of these Italian restaurants are dog-friendly?

Google lists Slicers Hoagies and Santi´s New York Pizza as places that are dog-friendly.

Which of these Italian restaurants serve vegetarian food?

Google lists Caffé Milano Naples, Mediterrano, Limoncello Naples, Santi´s New York Pizza, San Giuseppe Pizza and Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew as places that serve vegetarian food.

Which are the most affordable?

Caffé Milano Naples ($$), Slicers Hoagies ($), Limoncello Naples ($$), Santi´s New York Pizza ($$), Mercato Italiano ($$), San Giuseppe Pizza ($), Twisted Sheep Pizza and Brew ($) and Bruno's Italian House & Pizzeria ($$) are priced at $ or $$ on Google.

Which Naples neighborhoods have the most?

Old Naples (4), Central Naples (2), North Naples (2) and East Naples (2).

How is this list ranked?

By Google star rating, weighted toward places more people have rated, so a near-perfect score from a handful of reviews does not outrank a slightly lower one from thousands. Payment plays no part in the order.

Where can I find deals in Naples, FL?

Zipcode Saver lists live offers from local Naples businesses, free to claim, and can text you new ones two to four times a month. No app, no account.

By neighborhood

  • Old Naples · 4 of 10
  • Central Naples · 2 of 10
  • North Naples · 2 of 10
  • East Naples · 2 of 10

How this list is ranked

By Google star rating, weighted toward places more people have rated, so a 4.9 from a dozen reviews doesn't outrank a 4.7 from nine hundred. Only places with at least 5 Google reviews are included, one entry per business however many locations it has, and national chains are left out. Plan and payment play no part in the order. It covers every Naples ZIP. Places marked Local deal are Zipcode Saver businesses with an offer running now. Ratings, photos and summaries come from Google, last refreshed September 23, 2026.